10 Reasons We Should Disband NASA

by | Nov 9, 2023 | Quick Reads

The idea of disbanding NASA, a symbol of American ingenuity and exploration, can be provocative and contentious. So, the team here put together a thought experiment exploring the reasons some people might argue for disbanding NASA, in order to understand different perspectives on space exploration, government spending, and scientific advancement.

Funding Allocation

Critics argue that the billions of dollars allocated to NASA could be redirected to pressing Earthly concerns such as poverty, healthcare, or education.

Privatization of Space Exploration

With private companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin showing capabilities in space travel, some argue that space exploration could be more efficiently handled by the private sector.

Environmental Concerns

Rocket launches can have environmental impacts, including the emission of greenhouse gases and other pollutants. Some advocate for reducing these activities to protect the planet.

High Risk

Space exploration is inherently risky. The argument here is to avoid potential loss of life in extremely challenging environments.

Questionable Returns

Skeptics question the tangible benefits of expensive space missions, arguing the outcomes don’t always justify the costs.

Technological Shifts

As technology evolves, some believe investment should shift towards more emerging fields like AI or biotechnology, which could offer more immediate benefits to humanity.

Global Collaboration

Instead of competing in space, resources could be pooled in international collaborations, arguably making expensive separate space agencies redundant.

Nuclear Deterrence

Space programs can sometimes be intertwined with military applications, including nuclear weapon delivery systems, raising ethical concerns.

Outer Space Treaty Compliance

The 1967 Outer Space Treaty promotes peaceful use of space. Some argue that disbanding national space programs could be a step towards adherence to this spirit, reducing the militarization of space.

Shifting Public Interest

Public interest in space exploration isn’t always consistent. Some argue that government funding should follow public interest and focus on more immediate concerns.

In discussing the idea of disbanding NASA, it’s crucial to understand both the nuances of what NASA contributes to society and technology, and the arguments of those who believe its large budget could serve other purposes. It’s a debate that encapsulates larger questions about priorities, the role of government in scientific research, and the future of humanity both on and off our planet.

NEXT: The New Frontier of Space: A Libertarian Odyssey

AMP America

Get Amp’d in your inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter to get videos, articles, and more sent right to your inbox daily. 

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Share This