Should the Libertarian Party Dissolve? Probably

by | Nov 13, 2023 | Opinion

Guest post by John Lore

In a political landscape that demands a strong, unified front against burgeoning governmental overreach and fiscal irresponsibility, the existence of the Libertarian Party (LP) is a double-edged sword. While it embodies a crucial ideological stance, its practical impact has been less than stellar, often serving as a spoiler in elections rather than a viable alternative. The question that beckons is whether the LP’s dissolution and the re-channeling of its energies towards reforming existing political behemoths could pave the way for a more potent libertarian influence in the nation’s political arena.

One of the salient arguments for dissolving the LP is the perennial reality of the two-party system in the United States. The Democrats and Republicans have a stranglehold on the political landscape, a fact unlikely to change in the near future. The LP, despite its noble intent, has perennially found itself on the peripheries, often siphoning off votes that could potentially alter the outcome in closely contested races. Instead of being a conduit for libertarian ideas, the LP has inadvertently played the role of a spoiler, often to the detriment of candidates with partial libertarian leanings.

Moreover, the LP’s existence may be fostering a form of ideological purism that is counterproductive in the realpolitik of today’s America. By standing as a separate entity, the LP encourages a form of libertarianism that is unyielding and unadaptable to the complex, nuanced nature of modern governance. This purism often alienates potential allies and undermines the pragmatic adoption of libertarian principles within the existing major parties.

The current political climate is ripe for libertarian ideas, given the escalating national debt, debates over personal freedoms, and the overarching theme of government intervention. However, the effective channeling of libertarian ideology requires a pragmatic approach that may find better traction within the established parties. By dissolving the LP and encouraging its members to engage with and influence the major parties from within, there’s a greater chance for libertarian ideas to take root and effect meaningful change.

Furthermore, the dissolution of the LP could foster a greater unity among liberty-minded individuals. Currently, the libertarian vote is fractured, with some opting to support the LP, while others cast their lot with libertarian-leaning candidates from the major parties. This division dilutes the influence of libertarianism in the political discourse. A united front, forged within the framework of the existing two-party system, could amplify the libertarian voice, making it a formidable force in shaping policy and governance.

Additionally, the resources expended on keeping the LP afloat could be redirected towards more impactful avenues. The financial, human, and organizational resources committed to the LP’s operations and electoral campaigns, if channeled towards libertarian advocacy within the major parties, could yield more significant dividends. Engaging in primary elections, policy advocacy, and ideological education within the established parties could see a more substantial adoption of libertarian principles.

The dissolution of the Libertarian Party is not a call for the abandonment of libertarian ideals but a plea for a more pragmatic, unified, and impactful approach to advancing libertarianism. The two-party system, with all its flaws, presents a more viable platform for the infusion of libertarian ideas into mainstream political discourse and policy formulation. By embracing a strategy of engagement and influence within this system, libertarians can foster a broader, more effective advocacy for the principles they hold dear. The dissolution of the LP could very well be the catalyst for a robust libertarian influence that is sorely needed in these critical times.

NEXT: The Unyielding Case for Abolishing the IRS

AMP America

Get Amp’d in your inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter to get videos, articles, and more sent right to your inbox daily. 

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Share This