Voices from the Inner City: The Crossroads of Free Speech, Anti-Semitism, and the Black American Experience

by | Nov 7, 2023 | Opinion

By Joe E. Collins III

Growing up in the inner city as a Black conservative provides a unique lens through which the fabric of American dialogue is viewed, scrutinized, and understood. It’s a perspective carved out of an environment where the struggle for civil rights and free speech has been a palpable part of the historical narrative. This backdrop is essential when engaging in a discourse on the rise of anti-Semitism and the delicate balance of maintaining free speech while condemning hate.

The Inner-City Echoes

The echoes of the inner city are filled with tales of discrimination and resilience. For Black Americans, systemic racism has not just been a chapter in a history book; it has been a daily reality that continues to shape lives, opportunities, and perceptions. As a Black conservative, I’ve witnessed firsthand the importance of free speech as a tool for progress, reform, and empowerment. Yet, the rise of anti-Semitism – a scourge as vile and destructive as racism – presents a challenging contrast. It begs the question: how do we protect free speech while also ensuring it is not used as a vehicle for hate?

Anti-Semitism: A Stark Contrast to the Fight for Equality

Anti-Semitism, the hatred of Jews simply because they are Jewish, is antithetical to the principles of equality that have guided the fight against racism in the Black community. Having grown up in the inner city, it is clear that the battle against oppression is universal. As Black Americans have fought against the injustices of racism, it is our duty to recognize that the fight against anti-Semitism is a parallel battle against bigotry and hatred. Just as racism seeks to undermine the humanity and rights of Black individuals, anti-Semitism seeks to do the same to Jewish individuals. This common ground should unite us in combatting all forms of discrimination.

Free Speech: A Double-Edged Sword

Free speech is the cornerstone of American democracy. It allows for the exchange of ideas, the challenge of societal norms, and the ability to speak truth to power. However, free speech does not exist in a vacuum, and it comes with responsibility. In the inner city, speech is often a tool for survival and change. Yet, when speech crosses into the realm of inciting violence or spreading hate, it becomes a weapon against the very fabric of our society.

In our communities, we’ve observed the power of words to build but also to destroy. Anti-Semitic rhetoric, conspiracy theories, and stereotypes erode the mutual respect and understanding necessary for a diverse society to thrive. Free speech does not mean hate speech goes unchecked. As a Black conservative, the balance lies in vigorously defending the right to speak freely while also actively denouncing messages that propagate hate and division.

Confronting Anti-Semitism and Racism Together

Anti-Semitism cannot be tolerated under the guise of free speech. Similarly, racist rhetoric that aims to demean or diminish Black Americans cannot be excused as mere expression. As a Black conservative who understands the sting of racial prejudice, it’s clear that anti-Semitism must be confronted with the same tenacity as racism. The inner city, often a microcosm of broader societal issues, has taught that silence can be just as harmful as words spoken in hate.

The Civil Rights Movement taught valuable lessons about solidarity. Jewish Americans stood alongside Black activists, understanding that the fight against oppression is universal. Today, that same solidarity must be called upon to reject anti-Semitism and all forms of bigotry. It’s not just about being anti-racist or anti-anti-Semitic; it’s about being pro-humanity.

The Role of Education and Community Leadership

Education is the antidote to ignorance, and ignorance often fuels hate. Growing up, I learned the importance of education as a tool for empowerment. To effectively combat anti-Semitism and racism, educational initiatives that promote understanding and respect for all cultures and backgrounds are vital. Community leaders, particularly in the inner city, must also take a stand. They are the vanguards against the normalization of hate speech and are pivotal in shaping community standards for discourse.


As a Black conservative from the inner city, I am a testament to the transformative power of free speech. Yet, I am also acutely aware of the pain inflicted by words steeped in hate. Free speech is not just about the ability to speak; it’s about the content of that speech and the impact it has on society.

We cannot ignore the resurgence of anti-Semitism, nor can we dismiss the ongoing battle against racism. Both are stains on the principles of equality and justice. As Black Americans, our historical experience compels us to oppose all forms of bigotry. This is not about stifling free speech; it is about raising the standard of our national discourse and ensuring that our words bridge divides rather than deepen them.

In this journey, our voices from the inner city can lead the way in advocating for a society where free speech does not come at the expense of others’ freedom from hate. We can and must set a precedent that while our conversations can be diverse and our opinions robust, our collective narrative must reject the undercurrents of anti-Semitism, racism, and any speech that undermines our shared dignity.

Joe E. Collins III is a candidate for Texas State House District 70. Joe is also a Navy veteran and business owner. You can learn more at his website here.

NEXT: WATCH: Nick Freitas Explains Perfectly Why the Government is ‘So Bad’ at Customer Service

AMP America

Get Amp’d in your inbox

Subscribe to our newsletter to get videos, articles, and more sent right to your inbox daily. 

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Share This